Life is going great for Hannah, really. She's fallen in love with her best friend, her brother is getting married, and she's looking forward to another festive Christmas in Evergreen. Still, between her job, taking charge of the choir, and being the town's jill-of-all-trades, she's feeling uninspired...especially when Elliot starts to question his own role in the town.

Hannah finds fresh inspiration in the brand-new Evergreen Christmas Museum, and she volunteers for their storytelling project. When she interviews her fellow Evergreenians, however, she learns that not everyone wants the museum around; specifically Mr. Cooper who owns a third of the building. As Hannah finds herself with more and more responsibilities, and as her relationships with Elliot and her family grow strained, she starts to wonder about what she really wants. Can her love and newly-found purpose survive the changes that loom after the holidays are over?